Plaintiff v. Amerigas Inc.: $3,000,000 for Back Up Injuries

An Excellent Reputation
Built On Success
In The Courtroom

Nothing is more important than recovery and compensation for your loved one after a severe injury. 

Plaintiff v. Amerigas Inc.: $3,000,000 for Back Up Injuries

The plaintiff was a surveyor who was preparing to set up a surveying job in a public cul de sac in a small central California town. He and his helper were kneeling down in the middle of the street on a sunny Summer day facing away from an Amerigas facility at the end of a quiet cul de sac. The plaintiff was wearing an orange tee shirt and no orange cones had yet been placed in the street because the actual surveying had not yet begun.

An emergency call came to Amerigas and two of its servicemen got into their 15,000 pound truck equipped with a crane to respond to the call. The men had seen the surveyors earlier and also on their way to the truck. The driver relied on his side mirrors to look for the surveyors as he backed his truck and did not see them figuring they had moved. His first notice that he had backed over both of them was when be felt a “bump”.

Plaintiff, a 42 year old surveyor, sustained a crushed pelvis, a fractured femoral neck, a fractured elbow, some hot pavement burns and later developed impotence. His medical bills were $412,000 and his disputed wage loss and future medical needs brought economic losses to just over $1,000,000. The plaintiff was a renowned mountain guide, rock climber and back country skier and he contended that his injuries prevented him from engaging in these activities.

Plaintiff’s liability theory was that the driver was inattentive and violated nearly all of the “Smith” truck safety rules for backing up. He knew the truck had a large blind spot to the rear; nevertheless, he relied solely on his side mirrors. Plaintiff also contended that Amerigas aggravated the situation by blocking the back window of the truck’s cab with a tall tool box. Under these circumstances, the truck should have been equipped with a back up alarm although none was required by statute.

Amerigas contended that plaintiff also was negligent and contributed to his own injuries by failing to take simple steps to protect himself and his helper. Amerigas alleged that plaintiff was negligent for working in the street without cones, traffic control or a spotter when he knew that the Amerigas facility was there and it had truck traffic.

The case was venued in Sacramento County Superior Court. After considerable discovery the case was settled in June 2008 by mediation for $3,000,000 in cash.

Jeffrey R. Smith

Jeffrey R. Smith

Managing Partner

Robert B. Waldsmith

Robert J. Waldsmith

Partner, 1999

William B. Smith

William B. Smith

Partner, 1978

View All Videos

Video Center


Vehicle Accidents

There are two things to establish in any motor vehicle accident case: the cause of the accident (fault) and the full cost of the injuries and losses. As we prepare your case, we will investigate both of these.


Abuse & Molestation

 Priests, ministers, church officials and workers, coaches, teachers, day care workers, park rangers, and other trusted adults who sexually molest children, ruin lives and cause irreparable psychological damage.


& Serious Injuries

People suffering from a brain injury, spinal cord injury or other severe injury will require extensive medical treatment, rehabilitative therapy and other long-term care.



Claims related to sports and recreation injuries can be complicated. These cases often include issues involving waivers and the “assumption of risk” defense.


& Spine Injuries

When you or a loved one suffers a traumatic brain injury (TBI), life changes dramatically. Even mild TBIs can lead to years of recovery and rehabilitation.


Practice areas

The personal injury attorneys at the law firm of Abramson Smith Waldsmith LLP have more than 100 years of combined experience guiding clients through the legal process.

View All Practice Areas

Core Practice Areas
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


(415) 421-7995